The Philosophy of the “Babylonian Dialogue of Pessimism”

Time
Nov. 24 2026 at 16:00
Place
South Campus, room 4A.1.13
Organiser
ToRS
Type
Presentation
Talk with Ulla Koch and Morten Ebbe Juul Nielsen

The Dialogue of Pessimism is one of the best-loved texts from Ancient Mesopotamia. At the same time, it eludes definition because truly, it is one of a kind in cuneiform literature. Scholarly opinion is largely in agreement that the dialogue should be regarded as a semi-serious composition, dealing with the futility of human action, or as a satirical portrayal of the relationship between master and slave. Even if the dialogue does not follow the exact pattern of the so-called “dispute poems” it matches their humorous tone and discussion of strengths and weaknesses - in this case not of two concrete opponents, as the dialogue between the Ox and the Horse for instance, but of human life itself. The relativistic – or realistic? - view of all values and pursuits is truly unique in cuneiform culture.

However, it is not unique to human thought and similar ideas resurface in the 19th and 20th centuries CE. The dialogue has been likened to the thoughts of Kierkegaard and Camus, we intend to look closer into the similarities and differences with the ideas of modern philosophers, who even though there can be no way the 19th century philosophers knew the dialogue, echo its sentiments.

More specifically, we juxtapose themes from the dialogue with thoughts about the so-called “Master/slave dialectic” in Hegel; with one of Kierkegaard’s most famous writings form his Either/Or: A Fragment of Life, and to a contemporary discussion in ethics and theory of value concerning the incommensurability of values and the possibility of ethical decisions with no singularly right answer.